When to Fire Mr./Ms. Wrong: Knowing When to Cut Ties in Executive Recruitment
Recent Articles
In a recent survey, we asked firm owners and managers a simple but revealing question: What are the top two or three issues keeping you up at night? Unsurprisingly, 90% of the responses revolved around hiring, firing, and onboarding. These are some of the most challenging aspects of managing an executive search firm or recruiting business, and in this series, we’ll explore these issues in depth. For additional insights, visit TheRecruiterU.com and receive a free audio series on The Seven Deadly Sins Recruiting Firm Owners Make and How to Avoid Them.
One of the most frequent questions I receive is, “How do I know if it’s time to let a new hire go?” or, “How can I save a struggling recruit?” While the answer might seem straightforward in theory, executing it can be tough. If you find yourself uncertain about the right call, part of the issue could be on your end—you may not have clearly defined expectations. When expectations are unambiguous, the decision becomes far easier.
Setting Clear Expectations from Day One
The foundation of effective recruitment strategies for new hires begins in the interview process. Be transparent about performance expectations from the start. Let candidates know that, as part of the team, meeting specific targets is crucial—and that not achieving these metrics could affect their role in the firm. When these targets are both attainable and clearly communicated, it reinforces the standards of your executive search company.
A common error is setting lenient expectations during the initial weeks, focusing on quality rather than quantity prematurely. Early in the training period, activity matters most. Set targets that challenge but don’t overwhelm, and gradually elevate expectations over time.
This Applies to Experienced Recruiters Too
If you’re working with an experienced executive recruiter whose performance has dropped, it’s time to revisit the basics. Have a candid conversation, remind them of key benchmarks, and set measurable activity goals. With seasoned recruiters, take a collaborative approach by asking, “What should I do if you don’t meet these expectations?” This open dialogue often prompts them to evaluate their fit in the role honestly.
Empowering Recruiters to Own Their Performance
When expectations are clear and measurable, the responsibility shifts to the recruiter. If you outlined activity levels during the hiring process and they genuinely want the position, they’ll make every effort to meet those numbers. If they don’t, it may be because the role isn’t a good fit. For some, being let go can be less daunting than resigning voluntarily.
Weekly Benchmarks for Sustainable Performance
In my experience, setting weekly performance targets with daily checkpoints works well. Daily expectations can create pressure, but achieving weekly goals provides flexibility while maintaining accountability. This approach allows recruiters to manage their time effectively while still meeting the firm’s recruitment strategy.
A Real-Life Lesson on Expectations
I once hired a recruiter tasked with making 80 outbound calls per day. On her first day, she made 75, then left for the day. The next morning, I called her in to ask why she stopped short of 80. She shrugged, saying 75 was “close enough.” I explained that if my own role depended on hitting a target, I would exceed it to demonstrate commitment. Unfortunately, I had to let her go. While she was surprised, her coworkers weren’t, and it underscored the importance of meeting established expectations.
Setting these straightforward, quantifiable goals removes ambiguity from the process. Employees clearly understand that their performance is within their control, and when these expectations are not met, the decision to part ways is clear.